Finding a therapist can feel like one more task on an already full list. You open a directory, see a hundred names, and close the tab. Let’s make it simpler. Here’s how to narrow the field and choose someone who’s actually the right fit for you.
Start with fit, not just credentials
Every licensed therapist has training. What sets the right one apart is fit: whether their focus matches your life, and whether you feel comfortable being honest with them. A therapist who specializes in the concerns you’re carrying will understand your situation faster, which means less time explaining and more time making progress.
Do check the license, though
Fit matters most, but credentials still matter. In Arizona, anyone offering therapy must be licensed by the Arizona Board of Behavioral Health Examiners or the Board of Psychologist Examiners. You will see a few different letters after names:
- LPC (Licensed Professional Counselor) and LAC (Licensed Associate Counselor, still under supervision)
- LCSW (Licensed Clinical Social Worker)
- LMFT (Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist)
- PhD or PsyD (Licensed Psychologist)
All of these can provide good therapy. The letters tell you how someone was trained. They do not tell you whether that person will be a good fit for you, which is why fit still comes first. What you do want to confirm is that the license is current and in good standing, which you can look up for free on the state board’s website. A therapist’s license number should be easy to find on their site. Mine is LPC #17258.
Look for a specialty that matches your life
If you’re a woman juggling career, relationships, and the quiet weight of holding it all together, look for someone who works with exactly that. Specialties like overwhelm and burnout, boundaries and relationships, or confidence and self-worth tell you a therapist has spent real time with exactly what you’re carrying.
You can see how I approach each of these on my Specialties page.
Sort out the practical things first
Before you fall in love with a therapist’s website, know your own answers to a few questions. It saves everyone time.
Cost. Many specialists, including me, are private pay rather than in-network with insurance. That usually means a higher per-session fee, but it also means more freedom in how we work together and no diagnosis requirement from an insurer. That last part matters for privacy. When insurance is not involved, what you are working through does not become part of your insurance record. It stays in my HIPAA-secure documentation and nowhere else. If you have out-of-network benefits, a superbill from your therapist can get part of the cost reimbursed. HSA and FSA funds can often be used as well.
Schedule. Be honest about when you can actually show up. Weekly sessions in the first couple of months make a real difference, so a therapist whose hours fit your week is worth more than one you can only see sporadically.
Format. Decide whether you want in-person, online, or either. Telehealth opens up the whole state, which matters a great deal if you live outside Phoenix or Tucson, or if you simply do not have an extra hour for a commute.
Questions worth asking in a consultation
A short consult tells you a lot. Ask things like:
- What’s your experience with the concerns I’m bringing?
- How would you describe your approach?
- What does progress usually look like with you?
- What are your rates, and how does scheduling work?
Notice how you feel during the conversation, too. Ease and honesty are good signs.
Practical fit for Arizona and telehealth
In Arizona, a therapist has to be licensed in the state to work with you, whether you meet in person or online. Telehealth widens your options: instead of choosing from only who’s nearby, you can choose the right specialist anywhere in the state and meet from home. For busy women, that’s often the difference between starting and stalling.
What the first few sessions should feel like
The first session or two are mostly about getting to know each other. We talk about what brought you in, what you are hoping will change, and how you want to work together. My approach is collaborative, so you will have a say in all of it.
Then the work begins, and I want to be honest: therapy is hard work. My job is to challenge you and help you see things with a new eye, which can bring up more than you expect. That is normal. What you should also feel, underneath the hard parts, is that you are safe, that you are not being judged, and that we are moving at a pace you can handle. If you ever do not feel that, say so. A good therapist wants to hear it.
If it turns out not to be the right fit
Sometimes you have a consultation, or even a few sessions, and it is just not clicking. That is okay. It is not a failure on your part, and it does not mean therapy will not work for you. Give yourself permission to say so. Any therapist worth seeing will take it gracefully and, if they can, point you toward someone who may be a better match.
Trust your gut, then take one small step
You don’t have to be certain. You just have to be curious enough to have one conversation. If a therapist’s focus fits your life and the conversation feels honest, that’s usually your answer.
I offer a free 10-minute consultation for exactly this. Work with Mary and we’ll see if we’re a good fit. Outside Arizona? Start here.
Want to get a feel for my voice first? The Tuesday Pivot is my free weekly newsletter for women. Subscribe here.
